I know I’m not alone in hoping for some kind of Tim Tebow media blackout. I was hoping the end of the football season, especially with the Broncos’ defeat, would bring some quiet to the Tebow-as-Christian-in-a-strange-land stories. But Tebow’s move to the New York Jets brought a new round of media focus on Tebow’s style of loud public Christian-ness.
IMHO, the most interesting comment on the Tebow move came from Paul Moses at dotCommonweal. Moses noted that the New York press tended to gasp at the incongruity of an extravagantly Christian celebrity in the extravagantly pagan Big Apple.
Moses pointed out,
The Times put it this way: “Tebow is also a somewhat incongruous fit: an outspoken Christian playing in a city known for its extensive night life and a member of a franchise made famous by the bachelor stylings of Joe Namath and currently known for the profane speeches of its coach, Rex Ryan.”
And this, from the National Enquirer: “It is unclear how the pie-eyed pundit of the pigskin will respond to the multitude of temptations New York has to offer.”
Moses took such papers to task for assuming too much about life in New York City. New Yorkers are a decidedly religious group. Moses cited a Gallup poll from 1991 in which a majority of respondents–53%–said they prayed at least once a day. The problem, Moses claimed, is that too many people equate Manhattan with the entirety of New York City. In Manhattan, 17% of poll respondents claimed to be atheists. In the Bronx, that number dwindled to 1%.
As we’ve pointed out here before, people who do not know much about Fundamentalist America often assume that religiosity goes up only with distance from big cities, education, and indoor plumbing. It is just not true. The myth might come from the association in the United States of conservative evangelical Protestantism with conservative religion as a whole. But if we look at other conservative religious folks, New York City has as much of a claim to fundamentalism as anywhere else. In the Catholic Church, for example, New York City is now home to genial Archbishop Timothy Dolan. Dolan’s blog and very public presence inject a strain of conservative religiosity into life in the Big Apple. And, of course, outside of Christianity, New York City is host to innumerable conservative religious groups. The old joke about the hayseed who comes to New York and is surprised by the number of “New York Amish” demonstrates that New York has its own profound tradition of deeply conservative culture and theology.
Even within the bounds of conservative Protestantism, large urban areas have always served as strongholds. True, someone wanting a Protestant fundamentalist education could go to Bob Jones University in lovely Greenville, South Carolina. Or she could go to Liberty University in Lynchburg, Virginia. But she could also head to Los Angeles to Biola University, or to Chicago’s Moody Bible Institute or Wheaton College.
The roots of this commonly held misperception, I think, come from the utter dominance of conservative evangelical Protestantism in some rural areas. When folks from the big city drive around in fly-over country, they are shocked by the public dominance of this type of fundamentalism. But such folks ought to look closer at their own cities. Look for storefront Pentecostal churches. Look for big cathedrals. Look beyond the stereotypes of cities as home only to nightlife and paganism, and you’ll notice a deeply religious urban America.
There might be a few translation difficulties as Tebow moves from the Bible Belt to the Big Apple, but there will not be any lack of fundamentalists ready to greet Tebow as he (if he?) makes his New York Jets debut.